Returning from ACPA in Boston has been an adjustment. It is hard to believe that less than a week with fellow professionals can be life changing, but it happened. It wasn’t the big conversations. As with many of the life changing moments I’ve experienced it was small conversations and I would imagine the people with the most impact don’t even realize the effect they had. I hope to be able to tell them all at some point.
So one of the thoughts I’ve been struggling with since my return is finding my knowledge niche. Of course you all know it will have something to do with nontraditional students! I am passionate about serving Student Veterans, Students who are Parents, and various other sub-groups of our nontraditional student population. So how could I choose?
Last night I finally got around to rereading “Higher education journals discourse about adult undergraduate students” as well as reading “Changing the odds: Informing policy with research on how adult learners succeed”. A wealth of information that is slowly helping me narrow down where I want to focus.
Donaldson and Townsend (2007) did a study of refereed higher education journals from 1990-2003 and found only 1.27% of the articles published addressed the adult student population. This is astounding considering that the adult student population from 1999-2000 was 43% of all undergraduate students. In the article they noted that only three of the articles touched on professional development for instructors working with adult learners. (I would imagine even less for student affairs professionals working with adult learners.)
“Changing the odds” also has a section on professional development for practitioners in the adult education field and it is the first paragraph that has me thinking.
The ability to implement innovations and improve program quality is profoundly dependent on
a well planned and funded professional development system for adult educators – a resource
that is sorely lacking in adult education. The lack of a full-time workforce infrastructure with
a steady professional development delivery mechanism hampers innovation and continuous
program improvement. It is difficult for programs and providers of technical assistance and
professional development to roll out and build upon initiatives, disseminate best practice and
research findings, and connect student outcomes to teacher performance.
Perhaps this is my path. By becoming someone who focuses on the professional development of those working with nontraditional students I can fill a gap while still challenging myself to remain up to date on a variety of content areas. I have always been passionate about professional development, sharing knowledge, and fostering communities of knowledge. My strengths are in the areas of communication and information, and my style lends itself more to the administrative side of student affairs and learning than to the student contact side. (Although I do love that as well!)
A note about the difference between a nontraditional student and an adult student. As defined by the National Center for Education Statistics a nontraditional student meets one or more of the following criteria:
- Delays enrollment (does not enter postsecondary education in the same calendar year that he or she finished high school);
- Attends part time for at least part of the academic year;
- Works full time (35 hours or more per week) while enrolled;
- Is considered financially independent for purposes of determining eligibility for financial aid;3
- Has dependents other than a spouse (usually children, but sometimes others);
- Is a single parent (either not married or married but separated and has dependents); or
- Does not have a high school diploma (completed high school with a GED or other high school completion certificate or did not finish high school).
The more of the criteria the student meets the more nontraditional he or she becomes.
An adult student as defined by Donaldson and Townsend (2007) is one over the age of 24.
I prefer the term nontraditional student because it encompasses more of the student population and its characteristics than the term adult student.
So I have a lot to think about it. I hope you will keep coming back to read more as I process my way through this turn of events.
J
#1 by Cindy on March 28, 2010 - 6:23 pm
Quote
Jeanette… thanks for writing this post! I think you really did find a great and unique niche, particularly because you are talking about the professional development aspect of improving our knowledge base in student affairs.
What’s the next step for you with this information? I know a Ph.D. program isn’t always easy to get started on at a moment’s notice… but are there smaller steps you can take? What about a clearinghouse website for literature in this content area? Is there an organization already like that? (see the National Clearinghouse for Leadership Programs as a template, maybe?)
Glad you posted… I will keep reading!
Cindy
Pingback: Tweets that mention Trying to find my niche « Learn, Unlearn, Relearn -- Topsy.com
#2 by admin on March 29, 2010 - 6:38 am
Quote
Cindy,
Thank you so much for taking the time to read and comment!
A Ph.D. program is on my list at some point. Unfortunately funding is the current issue. As for smaller steps, I have a list! First is to start doing some serious reading and hopefully working with mentors to do some small studies. Once I develop a knowledge base I hope to start presenting on a fairly regular basis.
Your suggestion for a web site is dead on. Please see http://www.ntsaonline.com which I started over a year ago. It admittedly needs work, but I think this new focus is what I need to get me started.
Thank you again!
J
#3 by Rhonda on March 30, 2010 - 6:58 am
Quote
I think you have hit on an area that is destined to be a growth industry in this economy, and going forward. I really am impressed with the way you’ve laid out your thoughts, and have analyzed the population you’ve decided to focus on. That plus your passion for helping nontraditional students makes me think that you will be extremely successful in this area. Not that I ever had any doubt! That Ph.d won’t be able to elude you for long.
#4 by Sean Cook on March 30, 2010 - 9:34 am
Quote
Jeannette,
This is a really thoughtful and reflective post and I think you have definitely found your niche. It’s a pretty broad niche, so as you further define it, things will come into clearer focus.
You have a passion for working with adult learners, and the website is a good start. The idea is a germinating seed. Now you need to water it and let it grow.
Some questions to ponder as you hone in on your passion and bring it to life.
*Your audience: who are they? What do they want?
*How can you deliver it to them? Will it be you doing the delivery, or referring them to good information? Don’t discount the value of being a good referral agent, as well as a source.
*Are you connected to people and organizations that can serve your audience? Are these informal networks? If so, would it be valuable to formalize the relationships in some way (affiliate relationships, guest posting to each other’s blogs, actively referring your audience to them in some way on a regular basis?)
*What don’t you know? Who can teach you these things? How can you best learn them? And, importantly, what are you doing to be an active learner? IT could be a Ph.D. program, as cindy mentions, or it could be a self-directed quest, or a journey you take with a partner (or partners) to “challenge and support” you.
You have a gentle soul, Jeannette, and you give so freely to others. Take a little time to yourself to ponder these questions, and some new answers will come. When you are ready, you will know.
If you need any help getting there, please let me know. We should catch up soon.
Sean
#5 by admin on April 2, 2010 - 6:57 am
Quote
I <3 having you for my best friend.
#6 by admin on April 2, 2010 - 7:04 am
Quote
Sean,
We should talk again soon. I have been bad about getting back to you, I apologize!
I’ve been thinking about your questions.
But I can teach them to myself. I have outstanding mentors and connections. I am doing more reading now that I’ve had some time away from formal academics. I will also attend workshops and conferences that provide sessions on the topics that I want improve my knowledge on.
- I’m still working on the audience question. I have a general idea of who they are. Student affairs professionals, educators, and support personnel working with nontraditional students. Nontraditional students themselves have a wealth of resources that I will also be adding to the web site.
- I think I deliver the information via resources, but also as a direct source. I would like the web site to be a combination of my own knowledge and the excellent referrals I know I can make. I would also like to expand my presentation and speaking engagements. The more I get the knowledge out there, the more the students benefit.
- I am connected to some organizations and people that can serve as my audience, but I am also working on expanding those connections. ACPA was a great motivator! – good question on formalizing the relationships. I will have to continue to examine that one.
- I don’t know *a lot* of things.
Thank you, as always, for the insightful and thought-provoking post!
J
#7 by Cindy on April 3, 2010 - 7:16 am
Quote
Jeanette… did you present at ACPA this year (I forget..my bad!). The presentation phenomenon in our field is really interesting. Whether or not its deserved… if you stand up in front of a room and present on a topic you are deemed an expert. When people look through conference programs for information, they read descriptions and then look to contact presenters outside of the conference.
I hope you’re able to do some presenting in the coming year on this topic? I know pro development budgets are super-lean, but even local drive in opportunities are a way to build your expertise and reputation. Maybe work on a couple of rock star session topics where you cultivate two or three topics really well while you have some time?
Thanks for writing this… it forces me to think about my own stuff in this area too!
#8 by admin on April 7, 2010 - 9:29 am
Quote
Cindy,
I co-presented in 2009, but this year I didn’t have a strong idea of what I wanted to present so I decided to just take it all in. I’m glad I did because now I feel like I have an idea of who I want to become professionally.
I’ve submitted a round-table proposal for the Ohio Academic Advising Association annual conference in June. One of my ACPA Directorate (Commuter Students and Adult Learners) responsibilities for this year is to connect with state and regional ACPA affiliates as well as other professional organizations to seek out partnerships and advocacy opportunities related to our focus on commuter and nontraditional students. I am also planning to do a webinar with another directorate member on nontraditional students.
Now – how to turn all of this into Rock Star sessions!
J